I interrupted a discussion between a couple of customers* yesterday about a local teacher who was encouraging young students to practice their culture. Both were adamantly against it, stating that immigrants to the US should assimilate completely and become American and even went so far as to say that the teacher was un-American.
I asked what exactly American was, to which one replied that it was speaking English and embracing the American way of life and the culture.
I asked what exactly American culture was, to which I got generic and non-specific replies.
To me, American culture is a hodge-podge of international traditions and flavour (and the occasional refusal to stop using a "u" in certain words), and that's one of the things that make this country great. So many Americans define themselves by their heritage and as a result you have Italian-Americans, Asian-Americans, German-Americans, Italian-Americans etc. Everyone I meet tells me where their ancestors came from and most of them admit to retaining some practices from that culture. And why not? What's un-American about recognizing and embracing your history? It's part of who you are.
On the flip side, if you yourself moved to another country, would you stop being American? Suddenly give up everything you'd known your entire life, even forget it existed? No, you wouldn't. You couldn't! Most other countries wouldn't expect you to. In fact, when my husband moved to New Zealand, we included parts of his traditions in to our every day lives and in to our celebrations. Everywhere he went, people would ask him about America and American life. I get the same thing now that I live in the US. Even when I apply for Citizenship, I'll still be a New Zealander. I'll still be asked where I come from, and I'll still get the questions about my home country. And that's cool. I'm proud of where I come from, just like an Italian-Irish-German-Asian-American is proud of where they come from.
I agree that assimilation is necessary. I just don't agree that a person should be expected to completely erase their history, traditions and culture in order to appease. What do you think?
*For the record, one was Latino/Black, the other white.